Considering everybody knew where to meet and how to get there, Liliana didn't offer the several minute's grace she had last week, starting her lecture at nine am exactly. People were welcome to continue to help themselves to breakfast, of course - there were
mini-omelettes in bacon cups,
vegetarian mini-omelettes,
mini quiche bites,
hashbrown bites, and a variety of
breakfast crostinis available for the hungry, courtesy of Ignis, as
Liliana certainly didn't cook - but she was going to continue lecturing while they did.
"So, today, we have our first ethical dilemma," Liliana said. "It's taken from the short story
Those Who Walk Away From Omelas. This story opens upon Omelas, a wonderful society where there is no hunger, no violence, no kings, no gods, no masters. They are not a simple people, they have advanced technologies, they've cured common diseases, they have art and literature and science, and are sophisticated as any of us. But, more than anything else, they are
happy. Comfortable. All children are loved and wanted, all consenting relationships are celebrated, every person is
cherished, living not a life of pointless luxury, but joyful
abundance. Scarcity does not exist here.
( Those who walk away... )The end of her lecture, she sat back and looked at the class. "So, today's ethical dilemma is a simple question: go or stay? Do you stay and participate in mindful happiness, or are you one of the ones who walks away? Answer that and prepare to defend your choice--
but. Remember my rules. You are answering for this exact scenario only. You cannot stay and work to free the child, or tear the city down brick by brick. if you leave, you do not get to return with an army, or declare you're going to one of the surrounding towns. "Go forth, alone and into darkness, or stay and participate in society. Those are your only two options."
[Hey, head's up! Under the cut is part of the text of TWWAFO, specifically extreme neglect and abuse of a child. Be safe!]