[identity profile] clevermsbennet.livejournal.com
"Welcome," Miss Bennet smiled, and it could be said that her smile was a somewhat mischievous smile, today. "If you have taken previous classes with me, you will know that I do not typically favour final exams. Literature, for one, is a highly subjective topic, and the class was intended more to inspire individuals towards its enjoyment, than to quantify the understanding of it."

"Logic, on the other hand ..." This was not a very promising smile, no.

Miss Bennet began passing papers back, starting with the furthest row. "You have until class ends to finish, and if you should like more time, I am perfectly willing to stay after class with you. I am also willing to further explain any of the questions, should you require clarification. You may use any notes or books that you have carried in with you, but you may not leave to fetch any, and you may only use yours. You may not, under any circumstances, borrow another's notes, or discuss matters with your classmates. If I catch you whispering or passing notes while completing your exam, the consequences will be unpleasant."

The frown was severe, but faded soon enough. "Beyond that, dear students, I solemnly vow that I will be generous with evaluation. You have little to fear. Only show me what it is you have learned, and I will be well satisfied. Shall we begin?"
[identity profile] clevermsbennet.livejournal.com
Do not ask about the elf costume. Do not ask about the elf costume. If you value your life, do not ask about the elf costume.

Code of Conduct for Rational Discussion )
[identity profile] clevermsbennet.livejournal.com
"Good afternoon, class," Miss Bennet said warmly. "As you well know, we have, of late, been discussing problem-solving. Today I thought it might be interesting for us to apply some of the principles we've been working on."

Logic Riddles )
[identity profile] clevermsbennet.livejournal.com
Logic problems )

(ETA: I mistyped originally, so if you want to solve the puzzle, please note the tweaks to the statements.)
[identity profile] clevermsbennet.livejournal.com
Miss Elizabeth Bennet seemed in especially high spirits today, as she entered the classroom just before the bell.

Consider the Source )
[identity profile] clevermsbennet.livejournal.com
"Today," Miss Bennet said, clasping her hands behind her back, "is our last class before fall break, which means that we are midway through term. Thus far, we have been focusing on flaws in logical thinking; for the second half of the semester, we will concentrate more on ways to build a logical argument, problem-solving, and the like. Though I daresay we will still find ourselves looking at fallacies now and again."

"Therefore. Today I should like to have a brief discussion on anything regarding the first half of term - topics you felt were useful, areas you feel were not, or matters which were unclear, where you should like some enlightenment. Then, because I am not entirely as cruel as it may seem, we will be watching a film in which twelve average citizens are to determine the fate of one young man, if they can set aside their own preconceptions long enough to see the truth. After which, I should like for us to discuss the film, and the ways in which logical arguments played a starring role."

She offered a playful smile, at the last sentence. "So perhaps I am slightly more cruel than I seem? Nonetheless, let us begin."
[identity profile] clevermsbennet.livejournal.com
"Today, class," Miss Bennet said, cheerfully, "we shall be talking of two important principles of logical thinking, both of which discuss probability, but from opposite yet complementary viewpoints.

Of Razors and Swans )

Miss Bennet finished talking, at last, and smiled at her students. "Before we begin today's discussion, I should like for all of you to know that I will be holding office hours this weekend. Parents and guardians are warmly invited to stop in for tea, as are any of you, yourselves."
[identity profile] clevermsbennet.livejournal.com
Miss Bennet seemed a touch subdued, at the start of class. She had been male yesterday. It had been terribly jarring, especially when she realized she would not be able to pass the entire day without using the facilities. Students were advised not to inquire as to that particular matter.

Logical Fallacies, Part Two )

Miss Bennet leaned back against her desk with a smile. "We have handouts, as we did last week, and I will assume that you can infer from there what we shall be doing, for our class discussion."
[identity profile] clevermsbennet.livejournal.com
Logical Fallacies, Part One )

Miss Bennet stopped, finally, eyes twinkling with amusement. "And now that I've committed the fallacy of talking far too much for a class which occurs directly after lunch, I shall pass out some handouts, and we can discuss. Shall we?"
[identity profile] clevermsbennet.livejournal.com
When the students filed into class today, they might notice that each desk had a sheet of paper, face down.

The Forer Effect )
[identity profile] clevermsbennet.livejournal.com
When all of her students had filed in, Miss Bennet shut the door. "Welcome," she said, "to Logic, Reason, and Critical Thinking, which is quite the lofty title, I confess. It is my hope that class will live up to that ideal, but I do hope you will bear with your humble instructor as we fall short of perfection."

Self-Deception )
[identity profile] offthelisthero.livejournal.com
Mohinder was bouncing up and down on his heels as he waited for the workshop students to arrive. "As I hope you've learnt by now, logic and reason is not are useful but not infalliable tools in your armoury. There are times when people rely on gut feelings, trust their intuition or simply make a leap of faith."

"But if intuition really does exist, what could it be? perhaps we are all processing information, things we don't even notice," he continued, passing out handouts. "But sometimes it can see an irrational reaction, bringing up feelings about people and places completely out of the blue. Anmd currently the unconscious mind is very poorly understood."

"First impressions are a strong case of this," Mohinder was a little more thoughtful as he sat back at his desk. "There's no chance to assess the details of personality, and it can take work to contradict one that goes wrong."

"Now, whether or not you believe you use it," he finished, "We're going to test your intuition."

[OCD is up'n'at'em]
[identity profile] offthelisthero.livejournal.com
"If you're looking to win an argument, it helps not to be factually wrong. Particulary about something easily disproven," Mohinder began. "Your completely valid argument about penguin habitats will be really undermined if start off by saying they can fly."

"So," he said, handing out papers. "First of all you need to be sure of what saying. Generalising arguments might make an impression but gives your opponent a chance to pick holes, find exceptions, distract from your original position. If an analogy gets your point across, use it, but remember you haven't proved your point."

"It's not always about being right," Mohinder said ruefully, "But about being convincing. Ad hominem attacks on the person rather than their argument, threats of force, or bias of language - someone is cowardly or cautious, steady or dull - are all useful tactics if you can make them work to your advantage."

"Now, with those tactics - but without violence, please - you're going to try and convince each other of one of these arguments."

[And the good ship OCD has set sail!]
[identity profile] offthelisthero.livejournal.com
"Good afternoon, everyone," Mohinder started, his French just a little rusty. "If everyone will take a seat we can start to talk about encryption."

Switching back into English he began passing round handouts. "Not that one language truely counts as an encryption of another. One language may have words that lack meaning or nuance in translation and changing one to another is not as simple as running through a set of fixed rules, as anyone who's used Babelfish or equivalents will have found out."

"Our most basic form of cryptogram is direct substitution, one letter always standing for another, with various methods for assigning the codes."

Mohinder went on to summarise the logic and processes of a few more cipher techniques before finishing - "You should all have enough information to code and decode your own messages, or the examples. Or if you're feeling ambitious taking a stab at the Voynich manuscript."

[OCD is up!]
[identity profile] offthelisthero.livejournal.com
Mohinder was standing at the front of the classroom by the time the workshop had assembled. Written on the board behind him was 'Theory -> Hypothesis -> Observation -> Confirmation'

"We're looking at deductive reasoning this week," he said, passing out notes as he did so. "Where the conclusion of an argument is necessary - or has to follow from your initial conditions. Not that a valid argument has to be true - from 'All yellow objects float' and 'All taxis are yellow' the conclusion 'All taxis float' is valid, but not sound, because the starting premises aren't true."

"This form of logic is probably most popularly known from the tales of meta for Sherlock Holmes," continued Mohinder. He cued up the television, saying, "Such as this chain of reasoning about a man's hat," and this clip played.

The clip paused, Mohinder turned to the group. "Now it's your turn to construct a argument as to the events or people pictured in your handouts, and convince your classmates of it. I'll be here if there're any questions."

[OCD's up and the water's fine!]
[identity profile] offthelisthero.livejournal.com
Small desks were scattered throughout the classroom when the students arrived. On the desks were a checkered board, a stopclock, two closed boxes and two handouts.

"Computer programming is heavily logic based," said Mohinder. "Some of the earliest programs were written to simulate already existing games. The first chess-playing software was written in the fifties and forty six years later a computer beat a world champion under competition conditions." He backtracked into a quick summation of the rules of the game.

"Rather than using intuition or experience, these machines were programmed to sift through millions of possible outcomes several moves ahead, assess those and play the one with the best possible outcome. And on a more human scale that's what you're going to do today. Now, chess is only one of several logic heavy games - ones that have a limited or no dependence on chance - there's checkers, stratego, go..."

"Your boards are set up ready to play, so choose your game."

[OCD is up. Have at!]
[identity profile] offthelisthero.livejournal.com
Mohinder was standing at the front of the classroom, as he passed out a few handouts.

"Alright," he started. "One of the first points to winning your arguments is to make sure your opponent has the same frame of reference you do. If your company is 50 billion in debt you need to know if that's a million million or thousand million Australian, Canadian or American. Language and meaning change over time, distance and even how a sentence is put together can lead to it being misinterpreted."

"This can be exploited in argument or lying by telling the truth, or at least a precisely defined honesty and is invaluable in programming a computer that's smart enough to understand what you told it but not to know what you meant. Now, I want you try these handouts while talking with each other - see what impression you can make without actually saying anything false."

[OCD is up!]
[identity profile] offthelisthero.livejournal.com
Mohinder had pulled the classroom chairs into a broad semi-circle and was sitting on his desk, reading through his class list when the students showed up.

When everyone had taken a seat, Mohinder started off with introductions. "Good afternoon. This is the workshop for Logically Speaking - if you signed up then you should be here, and if you are here then hopefully the converse is true. My name is Mohinder Suresh, when I'm not here I'm a doctor of genetics from New York. Now, you know who I am I'd like to know your name, your point of origin and what would be the first thing you'd rescue if your home was burning."

After that was completed, Mohinder started passing round a handout. "We'll start with humour. What it is that makes us laugh - and that can be a product of our history environment and so on. But much of it follows a logical pattern. From the juxtasposition of unrelated ideas, puns or plays on sounds, practical jokes undercutting someone's dignity to the more contrived arts of coincidence and mistaken identity in comedy."

"Now, I want to try and make each other laugh. Verbally, please. Then try and figure out why that joke worked," said Mohinder, adding, "Oh, and Claire Butler? assuming she's here I'd like to speak to you after class."

[OCD is up. Have at!]

Fandom High RPG



About the Game

---       Master Game Index
---       IC Community Tags
---       Thinking of Joining?
---       Application Information
---       Existing Character Directory

In-Character Comms

School and Grounds
---       Fandom High School
---       Staff Lounge
---       TA Lounge
---       Student Dorms

Around the Island
---       Fandom Town
---       Fandom Clinic

Communications
---       Radio News Recaps
---       Student Newspaper
---       IC Social Media Posts

Off-Island Travel
---       FH Trips

Once Upon a Time...
---       FH Wishverse AU


Out-of-Character Comms

---       Main OOC Comm
---       Plot Development
---       OOC-but-IC Fun





Disclaimer

Fandom High is a not-for-profit text-based game/group writing exercise, featuring fictional characters and settings from a variety of creators, used without permission but for entertainment purposes only.

Tags