Advanced Criminal Justice, Class 14, Period 1, 02.23.06

[auroryborealis.livejournal.com]

[ooc: Hi! I have nothing to say, really. But there's always an OOC note. Oh! Wait, yes I do. I would totally have your grades for your essays up today, but um, still missing them from a couple people. If you don't get them in by this weekend? I'm not grading them, and you're going down a grade. Letting you know. Anyway. Class Info Post]

Rory sat on Tick's desk, looking very, very grumpy. All her limbs were still attached, though, and she was nursing a large cup of coffee.

"So. Hi. Professor Tick unfortunately couldn't be here today, so I'll be leading the discussion today."


"Last class, we talked about how Justice is implemented in Fandom. Do you guys think what happens around here is fair, as a whole? Furthermore, and this isn't just in Fandom, but do you think Justice can ever be viewed as subjective? Or, rather, the way said Justice is implemented.

I mean, let's say that someone, for instance, had nothing to do with the casting of a play, and she got horribly punished anyway, because the person who got cast thought it was in the name of Jusice to curse her, or something? Is that right, or wrong? Whoever cursed this person probably thought they were doing it for the good of the school, but they were misguided. Some might argue that Justice had become more like revenge then.

Once Justice is enacted due to a personal vendetta of sorts, does it cross the line from objective, fair Justice to subjective revenge? Or is there a middle ground? Discuss. And if you want to know what I'm talking about, ask me about my arms and legs. Seriously. I dare you."

Rory scowled, and paused. "Um, and for extra credit? Give me names of people who could conceivably cast a curse or whatever. Who live here. Who don't like plays, or brunettes, or something. Oh! And Logan, I need to talk to you when you have a second. After class, if it needs to be."

Comments

Talk, Notes, and Other Such Stuff [Class 14]

[auroryborealis.livejournal.com]

Talk! Ask Rory WTF is up with her mood and/or limbs! Whatever!

Re: Talk, Notes, and Other Such Stuff [Class 14]

[cameronmitchell.livejournal.com]

"I don't think that because there is some sort of revenge involved, that that means that you automatically can't be fair." Cameron replied, probably a bit too worked up in the subject as he found that Tick has pretty much told him the opposite. "As long as the person involved knows not to take it too far and is actually motivated to do the right thing. Blindly hurting someone because you think you've been done wrong however is just not cool."

He paused and stared at Rory who looked very much like her whorey counterpart right now. "You got cursed?"

Re: Talk, Notes, and Other Such Stuff [Class 14]

[carter-i-am.livejournal.com]

Sam shrugged. "I think that all Justice is subjective, to some extent. For instance, a criminal who is convicted won't necessarily think that's just, though the victim of the crime may feel that it is. Plus, there's the sentence--the criminal may think it's too stringent, while the victim or victim's family may feel that it's too light."

"As for personal vendettas," she thought of a certain jacket, "sometimes it's about making the proper statement so the injured person can get some closure."

She may have looked a bit confused about the arms and legs thing, but judging by the expression on Rory's face, today wasn't the day to ask.

Re: Talk, Notes, and Other Such Stuff [Class 14]

[janet_fraiser]

"If you punish someone for something they're not at fault for," said Janet. "Then it isn't even revenge. It's misguided, and I'd say that would be considered injustice."

Re: Talk, Notes, and Other Such Stuff [Class 14]

[oatmanspatient.livejournal.com]

"Feeling a little persecuted Rory?" Marty said with a little grin. "But to get back to topic: Yes. Justice is always subjective and will always be affected by a person's own bias."

Re: Talk, Notes, and Other Such Stuff [Class 14]

[mparkerceo.livejournal.com]

"I am so completely the wrong person to ask about this that I think I'd be struck my lightening if I seriously tried to pretend I'm not." Parker took a sip of her coffee, not really awake yet. "That said. Good things can come out of bad actions, for bad motives. And vice versa. It's all subjective, but the world may only suffer on a karmic level if the prosecutor of a criminal has a beef with the defendant. They still might do a good job of enacting consequences for the public."

Re: Talk, Notes, and Other Such Stuff [Class 14]

[notstakedyet.livejournal.com]

Angel looked at Rory worriedly. "Um - I think sometimes it can be both. Speaking as a guy who only exists because of a curse, maybe the intent is revenge but the outcome can be better than that if you let it."

Re: Talk, Notes, and Other Such Stuff [Class 14]

[fh_jackass]

"It can still be justice if it's personal," Logan said. "It crosses the line when the punishment exceeds the crime."

Re: Talk, Notes, and Other Such Stuff [Class 14]

[marsheadtilt.livejournal.com]

Veronica walked in to class ten minutes late, visibly annoyed, her hair shoved under a hat. It was possible that a few stray strands had escaped and if one looked close enough, they would notice that there was something green in them.

Additionally, if someone got close enough, they would notice that she smelled like Nyquil (http://marsheadtilt.livejournal.com/37562.html).

[not able to interact until i get home from work, but at least wanted to establish her here!]

Re: Talk, Notes, and Other Such Stuff [Class 14]

[fates_jaye]

Jaye, who spent a short part of her night on the ceiling, just looks tired. And freaked. Because... ceiling. Also, she might be kinda not looking over at certain parts of the room, not avoidy, in an avoidy sort of way.

"You know, there's nothing wrong with kill 'em all and let god sort 'em out," says Aeryn Jaye.

Re: Talk, Notes, and Other Such Stuff [Class 14]

[psycho-barbie.livejournal.com]

"I, uh guess it would depend on what exactly they did to you. I mean, just because horrible firey death is a bit much for a play casting, doesn't mean it's necessarily wrong if, say, the person slaughtered everyone you ever knew."

Re: Talk, Notes, and Other Such Stuff [Class 14]

[actingltcrumpet.livejournal.com]

Archie is here. He's just got nothing to say today.

Re: Talk, Notes, and Other Such Stuff [Class 14]

[aka-vala.livejournal.com]

Vala's eyes lit up. "Wow! You can curse someone for that?" she whispered in amazement. Possibly a little too loudly...

Re: Talk, Notes, and Other Such Stuff [Class 14]

[bridge-carson.livejournal.com]

"Well, in my opinion? Revenge isn't Justice. It's entirely possible to pursue Justice against someone or a group for personal reasons without tipping over into revenge, though."

Extra Credit [Class 14]

[auroryborealis.livejournal.com]

It can totally be verbal. Rory's making a list, omg.

Re: Extra Credit [Class 14]

[janet_fraiser]

"Maybe the Magical Theory teacher?" asked Janet. "Does she know magic?"

Re: Extra Credit [Class 14]

[oatmanspatient.livejournal.com]

"Someone from the I-club magic portion? Belthazor has cast a few spells," Marty suggested.

Re: Extra Credit [Class 14]

[carter-i-am.livejournal.com]

Sam considered. "Maybe Paige or one of the Halliwells?"

Re: Extra Credit [Class 14]

[mparkerceo.livejournal.com]

"Xander, Logan, Vala and Callisto don't want to be in the play, but Callisto and Xander both know Jake's ultimately at fault. I think Callisto's planning on pulling *his* limbs off." Parker cocked an eyebrow at the classmates named who were present. "And Logan can't do magic anyway, sooo... I'm thinking it was the pizza. In which case, the pizza guy just has a weird sense of humor."

Re: Extra Credit [Class 14]

[fh_jackass]

"Did you go into any strange closets lately?" Logan asked, thinking of the bunny incident.

Re: Extra Credit [Class 14]

[notstakedyet.livejournal.com]

"Draco knows magic," Angel said. "Don't know what he'd have against you personally though."

Re: Extra Credit [Class 14]

[aka-vala.livejournal.com]

Vala's really just having too much sick fun watching Rory pop her limbs off and on... and speculating how very much easier that trick would make some of the trickier pickpocketing and catburglary jobs she'd done never dream of doing, because it would be wrong.

"Um, if you find out who did this, you'll tell us, right?" Vala said, perhaps a bit too excitedly. "I, uh, mean so we can make sure it doesn't happen to us, of course.

After Class

[auroryborealis.livejournal.com]

Hi, Logan. Unless you grabbed Rory earlier. In which case, hi anyone who stops by after class.

Re: After Class

[fh_jackass]

"I didn't curse you," Logan said.

OOC

[auroryborealis.livejournal.com]

Because why not? Seriously?

And is everyone happy that I didn't do my comment threads as lyrics to EtS or the Killer Bees song today, omg?

Re: OOC

[bugofjustice.livejournal.com]

So very awesome. Thank you for killing me. Now excuse me while I hobble back to work all zombified.