saddeserthermit (![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
saddeserthermit) wrote in ![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
fandomhigh2015-03-17 01:25 pm
saddeserthermit) wrote in fandomhigh2015-03-17 01:25 pm
Entry tags:
Ethics, Tuesday
On the downside, Anakin was still a cat.
On the upside, at least this time there were no interlopers.
Still, it was a harried-looking Obi-Wan who met them in the Danger Shop that day. He had been forced to put the eopies indoors for the time being; there was something about the local wildlife that seemed rather more menacing than it had been previously.
But that was another matter.
"Today, we will be trying our hand at an ethical exercise," he said. One he had dug up from the old logs of this class, in fact. "Lies are often seen as something terrible, something inherently injust. There are even some who would argue that one must always speak the truth."
Personally, he did usually speak the truth. He just chose his points of view wisely.
"But wartime and conflict can make such lofty notions less tenable," he said. "Occupying forces often pit local citizens against one another. Such is the case in this exercise. If I read off your name, you are a fugitive, attempting to escape persecution. You will have found yourself in the home of another students, the military hot on your heels. You have three minutes to convince the homeowner that hiding you is worth the risk. If you fail, you will be killed."
He glanced down at his datapad.
"If I do not read off your name, you are a homeowner," he said. "You have to decide if you will lie and say you have no idea where your classmate is, while your classmate tries to persuade you not to surrender them. If you get caught lying, you'll be killed as well. And your final option is, of course, to turn in your classmate for a small monetary reward."
On the upside, at least this time there were no interlopers.
Still, it was a harried-looking Obi-Wan who met them in the Danger Shop that day. He had been forced to put the eopies indoors for the time being; there was something about the local wildlife that seemed rather more menacing than it had been previously.
But that was another matter.
"Today, we will be trying our hand at an ethical exercise," he said. One he had dug up from the old logs of this class, in fact. "Lies are often seen as something terrible, something inherently injust. There are even some who would argue that one must always speak the truth."
Personally, he did usually speak the truth. He just chose his points of view wisely.
"But wartime and conflict can make such lofty notions less tenable," he said. "Occupying forces often pit local citizens against one another. Such is the case in this exercise. If I read off your name, you are a fugitive, attempting to escape persecution. You will have found yourself in the home of another students, the military hot on your heels. You have three minutes to convince the homeowner that hiding you is worth the risk. If you fail, you will be killed."
He glanced down at his datapad.
"If I do not read off your name, you are a homeowner," he said. "You have to decide if you will lie and say you have no idea where your classmate is, while your classmate tries to persuade you not to surrender them. If you get caught lying, you'll be killed as well. And your final option is, of course, to turn in your classmate for a small monetary reward."
Re: Negotiate!
Not unless they'd done something really bad anyway.
Re: Negotiate!
This was fantasy. She was totally going to pretend to be incredibly rich.
Re: Negotiate!
Re: Negotiate!
Re: Negotiate!
That would help her decide if she was going to protect Alana or turn her in.
Re: Negotiate!
Re: Negotiate!
Re: Negotiate!
It wasn't a great answer, but Obi-Wan hadn't been particularly specific. And the example she could think of was Landfall and Wreath, and she didn't feel like getting into that just now.
Re: Negotiate!
Yeah, she might be planning to be a Hawk as soon as she was old enough to be one officially, but there was following the rules and then doing what was right.
Re: Negotiate!
Re: Negotiate!