fandomhigh | Anatomy of a Trial [Period 4, Class #7, 6-24]

Current Mood: frustrated

Entry tags:

anatomy of a trial

Anatomy of a Trial [Period 4, Class #7, 6-24]

"First off," Alex said. "Closing arguments. Only one of you went last week, so that means the rest of you should be prepared for today."

She set down a mug of hot tea and gave a somewhat sheepish look at her students. "Your final is ... less detailed than I'd intended. I'm afraid I've spent most of my free time this week dealing with some personal legal concerns. Be as brief or as exhaustive as you'd like, in your responses."

"And if anyone wants extra credit, then please research the ways in which one can obtain an annulment from the commonwealth of Virginia."

... No reason.

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

In wedded bliss. Or at least getting a little.

Hyuuga Hinata

Karla

Warren Worthington III

Squall Leonhart

Vance Astrovik

Brief though it may be.

Squall leaned back in his chair and gave everyone else smug looks. He did his work. He wasn't going to say anything to anyone, but he clearly felt he was better/smarter/less annoying than them.

For everyone but Squall, since he went last week.

(By which I mean, IC, everyone but Squall has to go -- obviously, you the players can handwave.)

Karla stood up and made her closing arguments, stressing how much damage that his actions have caused, not just in destroyed books and buildings, but in programs and outreach. She reminded people of his links to each of the burned libraries, painting a picture of a man who felt frustrated and angry at his own shortcomings and turned those negative emotions against the libraries.

It's short and it's sweet.

Voir dire is the act of interrogating a pool of potential jurors.

1a) Why is voir dire performed?

1b) Give two examples of helpful questions for voir dire. (Feel free to assume the case is your own, from this term, if a hypothetical is needed.)

1a) The voir dire is the process by which jurors are empaneled, so both the prosecuting and defense attorneys have a chance to select an impartial jury, weeding out anyone they feel may be unfairly biased.

1b) "Has any member of your family -- yourself included -- ever been arrested, or served time in prison?" and "Do you feel [x experience] will unfairly bias you in these proceedings?"

1a) Because most people aren't qualified to serve on a jury, so you have to weed out the ones that suck the most in order to get a marginally decent group.

1b) Would you be more inclined to trust a person's testimony if they are a police officer? Less likely?

Trials begin with opening arguments and end with closing arguments.

2a) How do the two differ, and how are they the same?

2b) Give one example of something which can not be included in an opening or closing argument.

Edited 2010-06-24 14:22 (UTC)

2a) In the opening you say what you're going to prove, and in the closing you sum what up what you did prove. They're both summaries of your arguments, though.

2b) You can't actually prove anything new -- that's for the rest of the trial.

Witnesses are called to the stand, then questioned by both sides (examination and cross-examination).

3a) What is the goal, when interrogating your own witness?

3b) What is the goal, when interrogating a witness from the other side?

The goal for calling your own witnesses is to build up and establish the facts of your case. The are the sources you are citing to prove that your version of events is the correct one. The more corroboration you have for your case, the less wiggle-room the opposition will have.

When you're cross-examining the other side's witnesses, you want to raise uncertainty in the witness's testimony, pointing out any flaws or discrepancies that can call their testimony into doubt. Even if you can't prove that the witness is wrong, you can certain raise of question of whether they're right.

3a) To establish facts that prove your case.

3b) To establish facts that prove your case, and to prove they're lying if their facts contradict yours. Or at least to make them look untrustworthy.

State one thing you learned in this class.

The judge is called the Honorable So-and-so. One can refer to them as Judge So-and-so, but never as Hon. That's an endearment and is inappropriate for the court room.

What? The lesson had stuck!

I learned the anatomy of a trial.

Thank her for doing a lovely job this semester.

Karla was there, her notes out to study when she wasn't making her closing argument.

Especially if you know anything about annulments in Virginia.

"Professor Cabot?" Karla stuck around after the end of class. "I wanted to apologize again for missing last week's class."

"It's fine," Alex said, offering the girl a smile. "I liked your closing. Is everything all right?"

(ooc: ... I so thought I pinged back to this. WTF FAIL.)

"It's...a little better now?" Karla said. "A friend lost her grandmother last week. Several of us went down to see if we could help out."

Catch said grandmother's killer. But Karla didn't think Alex would be happy knowing that little detail.

"I'm sorry to hear that," Alex said softly. "I'm sure she appreciated your support."

Edited 2010-06-25 23:20 (UTC)

"We got her through the worst of it, I think" Karla said, nodding. "Things were a little complicated, but they straightened out at the end."

You know, once they caught the killer and got her brother freed from jail. La.

"Good," Alex nodded. "You didn't miss anything of importance. People could give their closes last week instead of this one, if they'd prefer, and I let everyone try interrogating witnesses or polling the jury again if they were interested. I hope the final wasn't too much of an unpleasant surprise."

Karla shook her head. "I think you'll be amused by my answer to the final question," she said. "But it's honest for all of that."

Links to previous weeks:

HINATA: voir dire (http://community.livejournal.com/fandomhigh/2468632.html?thread=160285208#t160285208) • discussion (http://community.livejournal.com/fandomhigh/2476807.html?thread=161289991#t161289991) • opening (http://community.livejournal.com/fandomhigh/2484400.html?thread=161168048#t161168048) • feedback (http://community.livejournal.com/fandomhigh/2484400.html?thread=161168304#t161168304) • discussion (http://community.livejournal.com/fandomhigh/2493268.html?thread=161478996#t161478996)

KARLA: voir dire (http://community.livejournal.com/fandomhigh/2468632.html?thread=160285464#t160285464) • discussion (http://community.livejournal.com/fandomhigh/2476807.html?thread=160836103#t160836103) • discussion (http://community.livejournal.com/fandomhigh/2493268.html?thread=161487956#t161487956) • examination (http://community.livejournal.com/fandomhigh/2493268.html?thread=161488212#t161488212)

SQUALL: voir dire (http://community.livejournal.com/fandomhigh/2468632.html?thread=160285720#t160285720) • discussion (http://community.livejournal.com/fandomhigh/2476807.html?thread=160857863#t160857863) • opening (http://community.livejournal.com/fandomhigh/2484400.html?thread=161169072#t161169072) • feedback (http://community.livejournal.com/fandomhigh/2484400.html?thread=161169328#t161169328) • discussion (http://community.livejournal.com/fandomhigh/2493268.html?thread=161499988#t161499988) • closing (http://community.livejournal.com/fandomhigh/2509543.html?thread=162150119#t162150119)

VANCE: voir dire (http://community.livejournal.com/fandomhigh/2468632.html?thread=160285976#t160285976)

WARREN: voir dire (http://community.livejournal.com/fandomhigh/2468632.html?thread=160286232#t160286232)

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

Anatomy of a Trial [Period 4, Class #7, 6-24]

Sign In - ANAT07

Re: Sign In - ANAT07

Re: Sign In - ANAT07

Re: Sign In - ANAT07

Re: Sign In - ANAT07

Re: Sign In - ANAT07

During the Lecture - ANAT07

Re: During the Lecture - ANAT07

Closing Arguments - ANAT07

Re: Closing Arguments - ANAT07

Final (Ish) - ANAT07

Question 1: Voir Dire - ANAT07

Re: Question 1: Voir Dire - ANAT07

Re: Question 1: Voir Dire - ANAT07

Question 2: Opening and Closing Arguments - ANAT07

Re: Question 2: Opening and Closing Arguments - ANAT07

Question 3: Witnesses - ANAT07

Re: Question 3: Witnesses - ANAT07

Re: Question 3: Witnesses - ANAT07

Question 4: Miscellany - ANAT07

Re: Question 4: Miscellany - ANAT07

Re: Question 4: Miscellany - ANAT07

Talk to the TA - ANAT07

Re: Talk to the TA - ANAT07

Talk to Alex - ANAT07

Re: Talk to Alex - ANAT07

Re: Talk to Alex - ANAT07

Re: Talk to Alex - ANAT07

Re: Talk to Alex - ANAT07

Re: Talk to Alex - ANAT07

Re: Talk to Alex - ANAT07

Re: Talk to Alex - ANAT07

OOC - ANAT07