Tyler Durden (![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
tyler_gone) wrote in ![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
fandomhigh2010-01-17 11:22 pm
tyler_gone) wrote in fandomhigh2010-01-17 11:22 pm
Entry tags:
Build Your Own Philosophy, Period 2, 1/18/10
Today, the board read:
1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause.
2. The Universe began to exist.
3. Therefore, the Universe had a cause. - William Lane Craig
"What we're talking about today is called the cosmological argument , which is something that goes back to the ancient Greek guys," Tyler said after everyone was in their seats and the handouts were distributed. He was using notecards for once today, but didn't seem any the worse for wear for the blizzard. "It effectively says everything happens for a reason, and if you trace the reasons far back enough, they turn into proof of God or something God-like."
Yes, he thought that was dumb. But he was an atheist anyhow.
"For example" -- he held up his notes -- "I'm using notecards today. I'm using notecards because I usually research and write on my laptop, and I couldn't use it this weekend. I couldn't use it this weekend because my battery was dead and the power was out. The power was out because there was a blizzard, there was a blizzard because of the existing weather conditions, the weather conditions exist because of the atmosphere on this planet, this planet has an atmosphere because of God." A pause. "Supposedly."
"What I want you to do today is pick some random event in your real lives and trace back the chain of causes, then say if you think it's an argument for or against the cosmological argument. If you don't want to talk about your real life, I'm handing out radio transcripts so you can pick a real event in someone else's life."
He hoisted himself onto his desk and pointed randomly at a student. "You get 10 minutes to read and think about this, then we'll start the discussion with you."
2. The Universe began to exist.
3. Therefore, the Universe had a cause. - William Lane Craig
"What we're talking about today is called the cosmological argument , which is something that goes back to the ancient Greek guys," Tyler said after everyone was in their seats and the handouts were distributed. He was using notecards for once today, but didn't seem any the worse for wear for the blizzard. "It effectively says everything happens for a reason, and if you trace the reasons far back enough, they turn into proof of God or something God-like."
Yes, he thought that was dumb. But he was an atheist anyhow.
"For example" -- he held up his notes -- "I'm using notecards today. I'm using notecards because I usually research and write on my laptop, and I couldn't use it this weekend. I couldn't use it this weekend because my battery was dead and the power was out. The power was out because there was a blizzard, there was a blizzard because of the existing weather conditions, the weather conditions exist because of the atmosphere on this planet, this planet has an atmosphere because of God." A pause. "Supposedly."
"What I want you to do today is pick some random event in your real lives and trace back the chain of causes, then say if you think it's an argument for or against the cosmological argument. If you don't want to talk about your real life, I'm handing out radio transcripts so you can pick a real event in someone else's life."
He hoisted himself onto his desk and pointed randomly at a student. "You get 10 minutes to read and think about this, then we'll start the discussion with you."
Sign In [1/18]
Re: Sign In [1/18]
Re: Sign In [1/18]
Re: Sign In [1/18]
Re: Sign In [1/18]
Re: Sign In [1/18]
Re: Sign In [1/18]
Re: Sign In [1/18]
Re: Sign In [1/18]
Re: Sign In [1/18]
Re: Sign In [1/18]
Re: Sign In [1/18]
Re: Sign In [1/18]
Re: Sign In [1/18]
General Class Stuff [1/18]
Re: General Class Stuff [1/18]
Re: General Class Stuff [1/18]
That... sort of made sense, as far as she understood it. Like everything having an equal and opposite sort of reaction. She seriously doubted the whole proof of God thing, to be sure, but the basic idea of everything happening for some sort of reason, in some sort of chain...?
Well, that one, that one she liked.
Re: General Class Stuff [1/18]
Not taking notes over here, but Effy was paying an idle sort of attention and considering the ideas being presented.
Re: General Class Stuff [1/18]
Everything had a cause? There was a chain involved, that you could trace back?
Those were actually troubling thoughts for her. And she didn't particularly want to trace anything in her life back to what might have caused it.
Re: General Class Stuff [1/18]
Re: General Class Stuff [1/18]
Discussion [1/18]
Re: Discussion [1/18]
Re: Discussion [1/18]
He moved his hands lightly. "But you just found a place where this breaks down. We don't know how squirrels think, so we can't know why they do what they do. Most of us, anyhow." He wasn't sure about the pirates.
Re: Discussion [1/18]
Talk to the TAs [1/18]
Re: Talk to the TAs [1/18]
Re: Talk to the TAs [1/18]
Talk to Tyler [1/18]
OOC [1/18]
Re: OOC [1/18]