suitably_heroic: (dsp: oh ffs)
Atton Rand & miscellaneous names ([personal profile] suitably_heroic) wrote in [community profile] fandomhigh2023-09-05 10:42 am

Philosophies of Good & Evil, Tuesday

At the front of the class stood two figures. A man, hair short and dark, who looked to be somewhere between his mid 20s and his early 30s; he wore a black leather jacket and a Metallica t-shirt, and he eyed the class with a sense of bored disaffection. Beside him stood a blonde woman that could be anywhere from mid-30s to 40s, dressed in a green, tunic-length blouse and loose grey trousers, and smiling pleasantly.

Go on, class. Play ‘who’s the Sith and who’s the Jedi’. We dare you. (The woman's yellow eyes might give it away. If you were clued in to that sort of thing.)

“Hi,” Atton drawled. “My name is Atton Rand, and I’m a goody two-shoes who likes long, brooding walks on the beach, answering questions with really annoying riddles, and pretending meditation is a personality trait. Or, well, technically I’m just a Jedi Master, but you’d be surprised how many overlaps that Venn diagram has.”

Lana rolled her eyes. "And I'm Lana Beniko, a Sith Lord, who obviously enjoys torturing and killing people for fun, cackling maniacally, and taking over the universe in my spare time. Oh, and very large shoulder pads."

“They’re fashionable,” Atton said. “Somewhere. On the surface of the sun?”

"Some Sith would be better jettisoned into a sun," Lana admitted. "But it does make for very open architecture."

“Sometimes I daydream about jettisoning specific Jedi Masters I won’t name into the sun,” Atton sighed. “Anyway, this is the introduction class, so congratulations, today you get to slack off. Give us the basics. Name, class, where you’re from, how used you are to this kind of nonsense, yadda yadda…”

"And just for fun, define good and evil for us," Lana said. "In your own terms, but briefly." Look, she had to be a little evil.

“Like I said,” Atton said, faux-brightly. “Slack off, handle the softballs.”
outofthequiver: (a little uncertain)

Re: Introduce Yourself

[personal profile] outofthequiver 2023-09-05 11:55 am (UTC)(link)
"Well, no," said Libby, easy enough, half-expecting a response like that, and her expression went a bit more serious, "but, where I grew up, me just sitting here in this classroom right now would be the first step down a path to grave and damnable evil. Clearly, I disagree with that sentiment. In fact, I'm starting to find out that I don't agree with a lot of the things I was raised up to believe were evil. So I really do mean it when I say I'm still figuring an awful lot of it out..

"But if I had to say anything," she added, in case Atton still felt that was a bit of a dodge, "I'd say that evil comes from intentionally wanting to cause harm to others, while good come from wanting to make things better."

Which had all sounded much better in Libby's head, but now that she'd said it outloud, she couldn't help but wonder if that just made her sound foolish and naive.
outofthequiver: (shell shock)

Re: Introduce Yourself

[personal profile] outofthequiver 2023-09-05 08:23 pm (UTC)(link)
"I don't kn--" Libby started, but then she caught herself, frowning for a moment, her brow creased with thought. And then she shook her head and tried for a much more resolute, "Yes. I think so. I think that's why you sometimes can get good people who do bad things, because, to them, it is good, they're just...misguided. And that doesn't make them evil. And sometimes bad people can do good things, but they're not doing it for a good reason, and that's when things start veering toward evil. Of course, in the end, that's really not up for any of us to decide. I, um..." There was another hesitation, because she felt comfortable talking with Lana about some of these things, but she didn't know Atton yet, and everyone had been great here, but she still sometimes worried about how others might respond to all of her...faith, "well, I believe that it's really just between you and God."
unusual_sith: (Default)

Re: Introduce Yourself

[personal profile] unusual_sith 2023-09-05 05:40 pm (UTC)(link)
"Welcome, Libby," Lana added, smiling back. "What if intentionally causing harm to someone makes things better?" she asked.
outofthequiver: (stunned with hair)

Re: Introduce Yourself

[personal profile] outofthequiver 2023-09-05 08:26 pm (UTC)(link)
Libby's head tilted a little as she gave that a little bit of thought. "Well," she then ventured, "it's hard to really think of a situation where that might be true. I suppose...well, if you have to reset a bone to help it heal properly, that can be really painful, and there are times when...."

She trailed off, but then she nodded, clearly having worked out something within herself. "Yes, sometimes, that can be a good rather than an evil, but it depends. If your intentions are to make things better, then yes. But if your intention is to harm someone and it just so happens that good comes out of it despite that, then that doesn't really count."
unusual_sith: (Default)

Re: Introduce Yourself

[personal profile] unusual_sith 2023-09-05 11:30 pm (UTC)(link)
"So, intentions matter to whether a person is considered good or evil," Lana summarized. "Whether they do good or evil may be a different question?"