History of Medieval England - Thursday 6th Period: Discussion 6: The Magna Carta

[prof-methos.livejournal.com]

Methos is reading a frighteningly thick book. Be afraid. He looks up as people come in and sets it aside, ready to launch into discussion.



[[OOC: OCD threads are coming are up. Go postal. Homework this week is prepping for the trial.]]

Comments

Sign In: Attendence: MEH Disc 6

[prof-methos.livejournal.com]

------

DISCUSSION 1: The Trial

[prof-methos.livejournal.com]

Okay, folks. Do we want to have a criminal or civil trial? Is our plaintiff, Mr. Mitchell, bringing suit against our defendant, Ms. Mal Doran, for her property -- or her life?

(Much too geeky: Glanvill Online (http://vi.uh.edu/pages/bob/elhone/glanvill.html) -- a legal treatise written about 1188.)

DISCUSSION 2: Magna Carta

[prof-methos.livejournal.com]

The Magan Carta was not the first document of its kind in England. Henry I was pressured into signing a similar agreement. But he was not effectively kidnapped and forced into it, and even though the Magna Carta was initially set aside, it kept coming up in people's consciousness. Is an absolute monarchy better or worse than a monarchy checked by an equally unelected oligarcy?

DISCUSSION 3: Arthur of Brittany

[prof-methos.livejournal.com]

Since history is basically the study of gossip... as Ms. Parker brought up in class on Tuesday, King John was accused of murdering his nephew in order to claim the throne. Arthur of Brittany was the only son of John's older brother. But he was fifteen when Richard the Lionhearted died, and medieval nobility was uneasy about a teenager in charge. John at least was a known quanity.

TALKING IN CLASS: MEH Disc 6

[prof-methos.livejournal.com]

You should probably figure out by now that Methos isn't going to do anything unless it amuses him. Go wild.

AFTER CLASS: MEH Disc 6

[prof-methos.livejournal.com]

For all your after class needs.

OOC: MEH Disc 6

[prof-methos.livejournal.com]

What is it with evil English kings killing their nephews? Discuss.

[cameronmitchell.livejournal.com]

Cameron signs in.

Re: DISCUSSION 1: The Trial

[cameronmitchell.livejournal.com]

"Life?" Cameron squeaks a little as he realises that yes, he's going to do a trial against his ex.

Re:

[cameronmitchell.livejournal.com]

"Depends on who the guy on the throne is and who the oligarchy is?" Cameron said. "If your monarch is corrupt and there's an oligarchy to balance him out, then at least you got some sort of counter balance."

[notcalledlizzie.livejournal.com]

Elizabeth signs in, with a large cup of coffee.

Re: DISCUSSION 1: The Trial

[notcalledlizzie.livejournal.com]

"Well, surely the fact that it's a plaintiff bringing the suit, and not the prosecution, means that it's a civil trail," Elizabeth said.

[lovelylana.livejournal.com]

Lana signs in.

Re: DISCUSSION 2: Magna Carta

[notcalledlizzie.livejournal.com]

"Worse," Elizabeth replied. "An absolute monarchy is just a inherited dictatorship. Perhaps even worse, because of instead of taking power forcibly, they believe that they have a right to it; such as the Divine Right of Kings.

Sticking with England, but a few hundred years later, Charles the first was an absolute monarch, believed in the Divine Right, was an awful king, and couldn't control his own country. And he got executed."

Re: OOC: MEH Disc 6

[lovelylana.livejournal.com]

It's fun? ;)

[swerval_zero]

Zero signs in.

Re: DISCUSSION 1: The Trial

[swerval_zero]

"I, um, what Elizabeth said."

[mparkerceo.livejournal.com]

Parker signs in.

Re: OOC: MEH Disc 6

[notcalledlizzie.livejournal.com]

Well, we're not allowed to kill foxes anymore, so...? ;)

[aka-vala.livejournal.com]

Vala signs in.

Re: DISCUSSION 1: The Trial

[aka-vala.livejournal.com]

Vala looked more than a little disturbed by this thought. "No, no! No 'life' here! I vote for property." She pauses for a second, wincing. "Maybe just a little bit of property."

Re: DISCUSSION 1: The Trial

[prof-methos.livejournal.com]

"Actually, that was something that the monarchs were attempting to codify into law at the time, the idea that crimes were a crime against the state. At the time, there was still reminants of the Danegeld in much of England, where if you killed someone, you could pay a fine to that person's family and be free of guilt. So we actually could get away with a criminal trial with a clearly defined plaintiff."

Re: DISCUSSION 2: Magna Carta

[prof-methos.livejournal.com]

"But the action against Charles wasn't a democratic one, not completely. It was a faction of the duly elected House of Commons, but all they really did was replace a hereditary dictator with a theocratic one. And then, when Cromwell died, they invited the hereditary monarchy back."

Re: DISCUSSION 1: The Trial

[prof-methos.livejournal.com]

"So, you're okay with being found guilty and having your hand cut off?"

Methos might be enjoying this a bit too much.

Re:

[aka-vala.livejournal.com]

Vala was frowning, finally she gave up and asked: "Oligarky? Is that like Jaffa soldiers or something? Brave or otherwise? Because someone with absolute power can get pretty scary especially when it's over your brain and body too, and but a lot of people in the universe world seem to go for it."